
Photo © Roxana Gonzalez - www.freerangestock.com
I have been bombarded as of late with info regarding various online dating niche sites. I have seen repeated alerts, articles, and ads about sites for seniors, plus-sized people, animal lovers, the disabled, beautiful people (only), geeks, various ethnicities, and various religions. With the niche site trend gaining momentum, and so many niches to choose, from, how does a person choose the right niche for them?
I did a little research before I wrote this post by following up on the various sites. Approximately 95% of the sites I did a basic search on had no one who matched my very basic criteria within 250 miles of me. My criteria was male, between the ages of 35 and 55, and displaying a photo.
Of the remaining 5%, the few matches I got were overwhelmingly not matches for me at all due to other factors – primarily in what the men were looking for in a date/mate/relationship. Many were looking for ‘side action’ while involved or married, or for sexual encounters.
I checked out several dozen niche dating sites over the past week, and of those, I found perhaps 5 profiles of men that seemed like match possibilities. The criteria after my basic search was that the man was looking for a relationship (not sexual encounters or casual dating), he wasn’t already attached (he was completely single/legally divorced), and that he didn’t smoke and drink (I don’t). If I were in the market for a niche site to join, I would be feeling very frustrated at this point.
When it comes to online niche dating sites, there are multiple niches I could easily fit into. However, as my basic searches show, if there is not even one basic match within reasonable dating distance, it becomes a moot point.
Though my greatest level of success in dating and relationships via online dating websites has come from a niche site, I would guess it was the exception and not the rule. It might be age or it might be location; but for me, based on my research, niche dating would not be an effective way to find a mate. Your experience may vary.
A great way to sift through the niche dating sites before joining is to use the free basic search tool on their home page. If you get matches, be sure to read through the info with each match. One site I ran such a test on suggested some companion sites. When I tried the companion sites, I got results of people who matched the main site – not the companion sites on which I was searching. That led me to wonder if the search feature was rigged in order to encourage membership.
That was not the only site that I suspected had rigged results. Another site I tried also had companion sites, and surprisingly, I got the same numbers on each site. Each site informed me that I had a specific number over two thousand in matches and if I joined I could view them all. Each site gave me the exact same number. I find it doubtful that I actually had that many matches on a niche site, and that I had that same number on every site in their network. That tells me that either they are making up a number, or they are using profiles across all the sites – not necessarily the niche you choose. Either way, it makes it fruitless to join a niche site if you aren’t getting matches that fit the niche. For example, if you are a plus-sized gal and you join a site for plus-sized people and those who love them, you would expect any match to be plus-sized and/or be okay with dating a plus-sized person. However, if the site matches you with someone from their geek site that is not at all into plus-sized women – how awful would you feel?
Today’s Question: How do YOUR experiences with niche dating sites compare to those on more general dating sites?